Ethical conflicts, Nepotism, & corruption
continues to employ rogue prosecutor
Refusal to hold law enforcement accountable
allowed prosecutions by an unlicensed prosecutor
failure to comply with the national Brady List platform.
UNELECTED - Melissa Handke was appointed by Gov. Kevin Stitt after former District Attorney, Craig Ladd, retired amid public scrutiny.
Let’s quit pretending District 20’s Attorney, Melissa Handke, made some noble, justified, legal decision, when she announced she shut the door on Drug Court referrals back on July 8th. This wasn’t oversight. This wasn’t reform. It was a goddamn toddler tantrum.
Handke didn’t simply tantrum in private… she weaponized her position to punish a community service non-profit for refusing to do her bidding.
The cost? Human lives. Community safety. Fiscal sanity.
All torched, in an effort to feed her own fragile ego and hunger for power.
In May of 2025, a Jury instruction in Oklahoma v. May highlighted credibility concerns regarding Appointed District 20 Attorney, Melissa Handke's testimony under oath. Her testimony implicated misconduct by former Ardmore Police officer Eric Grisham, and Former Ardmore PD Forfeiture Officer, Current Carter County Undersheriff, Phil Sheppard. Both of whom assisted Craig Ladd in his malicious prosecution scheme against May.
May was AQUITTED on all five counts!
Under O.R.P.C. 3.8(b), a prosecutor is required to timely disclose her romantic relationship with a law enforcement officer in any case where the officer is to be a witness whose testimony could be subject to challenge. Failure to do so also violates Oklahoma Statutes Title 22, § 2002.
District Attorney Melissa Handke is married to former Carter County Undersheriff & former Healton Police Chief, Tommy "Gus" Handke. A sexual relationship is a material fact that defense teams could use to challenge witness credibility, and withholding such evidence could result in reversible error or even case dismissal.
Research uncovered at least seventeen court cases in Carter County with no indication disclosure to the defendants occurred.
A prosecutor's current or past romantic relationship with a witness implicates a personal interest that would create a “significant risk” of adversely affecting the lawyer’s judgment within the meaning of Rule 1.7(a)(2).
The relationship creates a conflict of interest and improper influence, additionally violating Rules 3.3(a)(1) and 3.4(a)(3).
Side Note: In 2023, the Oklahoma Bar filed disciplinary action against a former judge for failing to disclose his sexual relationships with prosecutors... During the scandal, Timothy Henderson resigned and surrendered his bar license.
Additionally, it appears Melissa Handke continues to violate O.R.P.C. 3.8(b), as there is no indication among public Carter County Court records of disclosure by prosecution of Mr. Handke's bias and mistreatment towards a female subordinate known since at least 2005 nor video evidence of Mr. Handke admitting to "giving breaks" and "working with" apparent methamphetamine dealers contrary to his duty as a peace officer to enforce Oklahoma's drug laws.
Familial relationships with a witnesses also creates an inherent bias that could affect prosecutorial decision-making, leading to unfair advantages or undue influence on testimony. The Brady Doctrine includes the duty to disclose evidence favorable to the defense, including potential witness bias. A family relationship is a material fact that the defense could use to challenge the witness’s credibility, and withholding it could result in reversible error or even case dismissal.
Concealing such a relationship misleads the court, undermines the fairness of the trial, and violates Rule 1.7(a)(2); 3.3(a)(1); 3.4(a)(3); O.R.P.C. 3.8(b); and again, violates Oklahoma Statutes Title 22, § 2002.
Research uncovered at least 20 court cases in Carter County with no indication of Mrs. Handke disclosing her familiar relationship with nephew, Tucker Halstead, Chickasaw Lighthorse Officer & former Carter County Sheriff's deputy. Sources also report Tucker Halstead is engaged to the daughter of Healdton Police Chief, Robert Roebuck, Jr. who reportedly had outstanding warrants while acting as Chief of Police in March of 2024.
Research uncovered at least 40 court cases in Carter County with no indication of Mrs. Handke disclosing her familiar relationship with nephew, Colby Copeland, Ardmore Police Officer.
Research uncovered at least 15 court cases in Carter County with no indication of Mrs. Handke disclosing her familiar relationship with nephew, Landon Copeland, Healdton Police Officer
Not only does failure to disclose her family relationships with law enforcement prejudice the administration of justice, it also brings disrepute upon the Oklahoma Bar and harms public trust in the legal system. Melissa Handke's nepotism has resulted in due process and Brady violations in at least NINETY TWO cases in total. Once ethical defense attorneys discover these undisclosed relationships, it could lead to mistrials, ineffective assistance of counsel claims, and overturned convictions.
Melissa Handke continues to employ Fern L. Smith Ok Bar #8347. After years of publicly document misconduct, rumors were planted within the Johnston County courthouse of her retirement, only for Handke to then transfer Smith to Murray County amid Richard Glossip's pending SCOTUS appeal.
In order to begin identifying ALL wrongful convictions that have occurred as a result of Fern Smith's prosecutorial misconduct, Melissa Handke has a duty under O.R.P.C. 3.8 to IMMEDIATELY report Smith to the bar association and implement an independent conviction review unit for Johnston County [and now Murray County].
Despite this duty being publicized for over a year, Handke has only taken steps to obscure the judicial crisis by transferring Fern Smith to Murray County under the guise of retirement.
Once Melissa Handke became aware of public knowledge & concern surrounding Smith's integrity, then failed to discipline and report Smith to the Oklahoma Bar, Handke was in violation of Rule 8.3. This is because the failure to report undermines the integrity of the legal profession and harms the public trust in the legal system.
Former Carter County Sheriff, Chris Bryant, has more than 5 Brady List Reports
and is one of Oklahoma's RICO Sheriffs.
Johnston County Sheriff, Gary Dodd, has more than 50 Brady List Reports
and is one of Oklahoma's RICO Sheriffs.
Oklahoma State Court Network [OSCN as of 11/10/2023] shows 442 records for Carter County where Alexis Benitez is listed on court records as “District Attorney” despite not passing the state bar examination and lacking the statutory qualifications to hold the position. During that time, Benitez only held a limited license for a “Legal Internship” with the Oklahoma Bar Association. That license was renewed on September 22, 2023, presumably due to his inability to pass the Oklahoma Bar Exam he sat for in July of 2023. Read More...
Melissa Handke has the power and authority via her position as District Attorney to implement the National Brady List platform within Carter County, Love County, Johnston County, Marshall County and Murray County, by contributing her district's data.
This would ensure fair trials occurred in the manner prescribed when the Supreme Court of the United States created the Brady doctrine, obligating the prosecutor of every case to investigate, gather, and disclose all information about any individual upon whose testimony they will rely.
with the with the nationwide, public-facing, platform of record: The Brady List;
Attorney Generals, as prosecutors, have ethical obligations and may be held individually accountable under the Rules of Professional Conduct [R.P.C.] for their conduct within the legal system. Violations of these Rules can result in disciplinary actions which may include sanctions, suspension, or disbarment.
By Phone: (580) 223-9674
By email: melissa.handke@dac.state.ok.us
By Mail: Annex #1, 107 1st Ave SW Suite A, Ardmore, OK 73401